Maintaining balance between demands, expectations and fulfillment drives success.
By R. Dana Barlow

A wise(acre) supply chain executive at a prominent East Coast integrated delivery network (IDN) once noted that the team knows when it’s doing a good job if the telephone isn’t ringing from an internal line and the emails aren’t piling up.
Some may define customer experience as the feeling they get when you give them what they want. Others may add the brusque “within reason” to those demands. Still others may classify it as providing people with what (you think) they need.
For supply chain, the sweet spot may reside within the intersection of those three circles.
What’s noteworthy? None of the three makes absolutely everyone happy, so the goal may be to provide as much balance as possible by optimizing decisions. This may involve playing the long game to develop trust and mitigate results, according to healthcare supply chain executives.
Within the pressure-cooker healthcare environment, however, some may find waiting patiently for something or someone a bit of a challenge.
Defining customer experience (CX) varies. For some, it’s availability, breadth and depth of product choices. For others, it’s a friendly face and/or a calming voice that assures them that they’re in good hands and shape.
Some rally around the banner of “customer centricity,” as in putting the customers first by anticipating needs, predicting market demands and maintaining a position ahead of customer expectations. It may be magic, it may be chance, or it may be driven by automation in the form of artificial intelligence (A.I.) or decision-support software.
The overarching premise may be to find balance between the demands of customers and that of the supply chain to meet in the middle and move forward together. Or does supply chain need to be at least one step ahead as much as possible – versus two steps back?
Definitive dilemma
CX can mean different things to different people within a seemingly unified group – say, supply chain. Each executive, leader, manager and professional harbors his or her delineation between what it is and what it is not. None is wrong; they’re all right – to an extent.
“The term ‘customer experience’ takes on different definitions based on the types of products and services,” Tom Lubotsky, vice president and Chief Supply Chain Officer, Allina Health, Minneapolis, told The Journal of Healthcare Contracting. “At the end of the day, our primary customer is the patient or consumer of our healthcare services. At Allina, we wish to be our community’s most trusted health ally by providing access to specialty and preventive care when, where and how they need it.
“Supply Chain supports this vision by ensuring we act as an ally with our care partners through the assurance of products and services, especially those that are directly or supporting this access to care,” Lubotsky continued. “This customer experience heavily depends on our products being delivered on time and in full when they need it. If we are addressing specific clinical services agreements that support patient care, then the specific service level agreements (SLAs) define the customer experience needed to support patient care properly. For capital equipment, the reliance of keeping equipment functioning at all times is essential and hence the customer service of fulfilling uptime rates is critical.”
Steve Downey, vice president, Chief Supply Chain & Support Services Officer, Cleveland Clinic, classifies CX based on the role Supply Chain plays in the overall healthcare enterprise, which extends beyond the organization itself.
“We are a shared service for the enterprise, in the end serving the patients,” Downey indicated. “Our stakeholders are the executive team, hospital operations, caregivers and fellow operations team members that need our services. Those customers interface with us from their own lens, which may include the full range of supply chain functions. Service may mean visibility to status – like where is my contract? – to performance of the function – like driving the lowest possible price for the selected product or service. It may also include overall management of the supply chain and delivering it using our expertise. We have agreed upon [objectives and key results] that outline the level of service that we provide and budgets to determine how much it will cost for us to do it. Poor service is noticeable, and comes as backorders, shortages, high pricing, budget misses, delayed contracts or poor OKRs.”
One way to look at customer experience is to view it from their point of view, according to Joe Colonna, Chief Supply Chain & Project Management Officer, Atlanta-based Piedmont Healthcare.
“From the perspective of being a customer of supply chain, there is the day-to-day operational experience, and that is strait forward – ‘Do I have a high degree of confidence that I will have what I need, when I need it, on time every time?’ Does the customer have confidence that the supply chain team will always have my back when it comes to this very simple statement? Is there an easy-to-understand process for addressing concerns and do I feel like the supply chain team is a real partner in helping me make sure I have what I need to do my job?
“The more complicated aspect of the relationship is the management of expenses,” Colonna continued. “Often, Supply Chain is in the position of having to say ‘no’ to a request that may increase costs or do not align with a larger strategy. In those cases, customer service – to me – means that while a customer may not like that answer, they understand that process and feel that they are being heard, and Supply Chain does a good job of explaining the reasons behind that denial of their request.”
Eric Tritch, senior vice president, Supply Chain & Support Services, UChicago Medicine, homes in on the patient as the primary customer, which he believes should be his team’s focus.
“We have many secondary customers – the family, the clinical teams, etc. – but it starts with the patient,” Tritch acknowledged. “We need to be relentless to drive value for the patient in our work and keep that lens. I like to think about envisioning the experience or story of what an excellent customer experience looks and feels like and then also what a bad customer experience looks and feels like. When given the opportunity, it is important to share stories with the teams about times we got it right and times we got it wrong to build the culture. Often Supply Chain isn’t interacting directly with patients, so it becomes how we can support staff and caregivers to allow them to be their best and provide an excellent experience?”
Supply Chain, in a way, should take it personally, according to Tritch.
“I’ve used stories from my own experiences as a patient or family member of a patient,” he recommended. “One time Supply Chain clearly got it wrong was when I was told they were out of pillows, and I’d need to lay on a rolled-up towel!
“We have a mantra to provide efficient, responsive and effective service while driving value: Efficiency in not being wasteful with resources to get the result, responsive in quick turnaround and resolution and effective in getting the job done right the first time and leaving our customers highly satisfied,” he explained.
Mark Dozier, associate vice president, Supply Chain Services, Strategic Sourcing & Engagement, HonorHealth, Scottsdale, AZ, oversees sourcing and contracting for his IDN, and notes that his team’s primary function influences his perspective.
“Customer experience is the process and outcome of 1) interacting with Supply Chain, 2) utilizing services from Supply Chain, and 3) using products, equipment and services selected and provided by Supply Chain,” he said.
Dinging customer service
Customer service tends to be an influential component that makes or breaks customer experience, and all it may take is one primary complaint – spanning a single incident to a consistent series of incidents – for everything to go south.
Supply Chain executives itemize a series of complaints as consistent common denominators.
“The biggest misses come from not having the right product to serve patients, paying too much for those products, contracts taking too long to source and missed OKRs,” observed Cleveland Clinic’s Downey. “These all directly affect the bottom line or the ability to serve the patients or enterprise.”
Piedmont’s Colonna concurs. “Primary complaints tend to be around a lack of product availability. A close second would be the denial of new product requests. Overarching would be a lack of understanding around how Supply Chain processes work. All of these can create the perception that Supply Chain is not being responsive to customer requests and/or do not understand the needs of the operation,” he indicated.
UChicago Medicine’s Tritch harkens back to the wisdom of a former mentor. “I use a quote that my old boss Karl Hurston used to say, ‘that at the end of the day, they won’t remember how much money you saved; they will remember if you got the job done and if they liked working with you.’ Now this doesn’t mean we don’t have financial targets to achieve, but it does mean you can’t drag things out or upset everyone along the way to get a result, or you won’t get the opportunity for too long.”
Tritch questions whether a single primary complaint can be applied universally. “It could be the result wasn’t achieved, it could be the approach or communication was poor, it could be that the result took too long, it could be that it was clunky and difficult to get it done. This gets back to Efficient, Responsive and Effective,” he said.
HonorHealth’s Dozier points to “product backorders, substitutions and recalls” as having been at the top of the list for the past four years.
“One of my value analysis nurses calls it ‘Backorder Armageddon,’ he quipped. “Nursing staff are weary of having to learn/get comfortable with a substitute product due to the contracted product not being available. It has happened way too much since the start of the 2020 pandemic, and it continues.”
Allina’s Lubotsky recognizes this as well. “Clearly, not having the right products at the time needed is a primary complaint,” he agreed. “Backorders and shortages may create issues of having the product available and when properly substituted with an approved product, many caregivers and physicians would prefer having the product they are accustomed to using in providing the safest, reliable care. Downtime of clinical capital equipment can also be a primary dissatisfier creating issues with patient access and rescheduling that leads to unnecessary delays of patient care.”
Clearing the hurdle
What might be the top challenge Supply Chain faces in providing positive customer service?
For Colonna, it starts with one thing in triplicate.
“Communication, communication, communication,” he emphasized. “For example, too often Supply Chain assumes that their customers understand challenges to providing products or services, when, in fact, they do not. This lack of understanding leaves a vacuum that can be filled by rumors and negative assumptions on the part of the customer. Consistent and timely communication on changes that impact supply availability and including end users in mitigation efforts can build understanding and partnership to face challenges together.”
Tritch echoes the communications gap derailing the customer experience due to perceived customer service shortcomings.
“I’ve seen where teams can get too focused on an insular view or focused on being frustrated with a customer that didn’t follow the process exactly the way they wanted them to,” he lamented. “I challenge my teams and leaders with the old mantra that the customer is always right. Not that you don’t need partners and stakeholders to do their part, but you need to focus on the things that you can control. It is one thing if someone is intentionally trying to sabotage or do the wrong thing, then that needs to be addressed; but more often than not, people want to get it right and do a good job, so you need to focus on what failed them in the process, training, technology and how you can help make it easier to get it right every time.”
Dozier references staff turnover as having a big impact. “We have to continually educate end users on our processes, timelines and tools. For many clinical staff, once they see the light and grasp our tools and processes, they soon move on to a new employer. The consistent turnover among our customer service lines is having an impact on a positive customer experience,” he indicated.
Lubotsky insists that Supply Chain maintains its discipline of identifying and measuring key service levels associated with products and services. “Without this conviction, it will always be difficult to show evidence of customer service expected and the understood gaps to address for improvement,” he noted. “Establishing a strong resilient set of standards and practices to mitigate unexpected product delays is essential today to offer nimble capabilities as well.”
Downey issues a four-part, full-court press to ensure customer service and assure a positive customer experience.
- “Align expectations with those stakeholders, ensure aligned goals, create active dialogue to ensure you’re listening and understanding performance and needs
- “Have the right information, with correct data. Nothing breaks confidence faster than not having the right data behind a discussion.
- “Ensure you have the right systems for the job: Inventory management systems that control product on the shelf meets demand and ordering systems that allow end users a seamless request experience.
- “Visibility to their needs. If a contract is in queue, know where it is, when will it be completed, how do we expedite and why is it stuck,” he suggested.
Aiming too high?
Occasionally, Supply Chain may encounter customer service challenges that might never be overcome to improve customer experience for someone. Achieving some sense of balance may be critical, but difficult.
“We strive to give automation for the customer, so they don’t need to think about or spend time about supply chain related tasks and things are just there when they need them,” Tritch said. “However, this isn’t realistic, and I believe we need to keep our stakeholders engaged in all levels to some extent, but it is balancing that they are not burdened by non-value-added tasks to get what they need to take care of patients or educate or do research. There are balances to strike as well between cost, quality and outcomes. I could keep 90 days of every possible product option in my warehouse at all times, but that would be incredibly wasteful from a cost perspective, so you need to strike a balance that doesn’t hurt the business.”
Dozier cites convenience among physicians, nurses and allied health staff, for example. “A number of supply chain customers want choice. They do not want to be forced to use just one supplier for a product (e.g., trocars, biologics, surgeon gloves, lotions). These customers often resist complying with our formulary product. I don’t see this struggle of standardization versus choice going away.”
Fulfillment demands due to the world around us consistently may fall short, according to Lubotsky. “Key causes of products not being filled on time and in full can rest with geopolitical, climate, regulatory changes that are difficult to overcome. We are clearly facing today the uncertainty of tariff trade policies that seem to waver greatly, creating supply chain complexities that are becoming incredibly challenging and demanding a stronger forecasting and demand-planning capability requirement. Setting up an environment to proactively anticipate these factors is at best difficult, but one that is needed to stabilize product delays and deficiencies,” he asserted.
Downey turns to product or service availability. “Contracting for something and then it not being on the shelf or available doesn’t help, so choose and manage it wisely, with performance measures and [key performance indicators]. We will never get 100% availability of every SKU every time, but ensuring substitutes are available and approved ahead of time are possible,” he noted.
Colonna hints at good parenting skills; namely, “balancing cost management and letting the customer have what they ‘need’ instead of what they ‘want.’ Managing a relationship to understand and address the need and not the want is an ongoing and important conversation in an industry where new technology is constantly evolving,” he recommended.
Finding a happy medium moot
Meeting somewhere in the middle might not be the optimal strategy and tactic to take, supply chain executives contend, but it may be more realistic.
Dozier blames simple economics. “Continual financial headwinds and staff turnover apply plenty of pressure to Supply Chain to arrive at a world of ‘cost-effective’ care and ‘satisfied’ physicians, nurses and allied health staff,” he observed.
But something must be done, according to Lubotsky. “There will have to be a mindset to address the improvements needed if we want to provide exceptional customer service. Simply accepting the status quo of living with mediocre customer service should never be the norm, especially as it pertains to delivering patient care in the most optimal, safe and reliable manner. Meeting in the middle to deliver customer services is unacceptable. It simply breeds mediocrity without an energy of ‘knock your socks out’ customer service,” he warned.
Downey dismisses the notion of “happy medium” as a cop-out “because that means you have unhappy customers and aren’t striving for the service they need or expect. While it may not be feasible to have years of inventory available to avoid shortages, strategic investments and planning can solve shortages, systems can solve visibility and relationships can solve aligned goals,” he emphasized.
Mediocrity can be more dangerous than comfortable, according to Colonna.
“This can lead to scenarios where everyone gets what they want at an ‘ok’ price, which then leads to operational challenges associated with managing excessive inventory and in many cases duplicating products. Financially, you are unlikely to achieve competitive prices by carrying all the competitors who make the same types of products,” he concluded.
Tritch urges contemplating the full picture. “The biggest concern here is that we can’t settle when it comes to patient care. What does that look like? Is it okay to have a few bad outcomes? Is it okay to get it wrong some percent of the time? No, absolutely not. That doesn’t mean anyone is perfect, but we can’t settle for mediocrity. On the flip side, there are times where driving incremental improvement is the best way forward and not preventing real progress just because it isn’t perfect yet.”
When customer service bolsters customer experience

Five healthcare supply chain executives and leaders share examples of customer service that positively impacted the customer experience.
“There are numerous examples of strong collaboration among suppliers including distributors and providers that work each day rigorously to provide the needed products in delivering care to patients in our communities. This collaboration rests with strong communication channels, responsiveness and often creative solutions to address these daily needs. Establishing these frameworks and behaviors engender trust and a learning environment to address improvements and a more reliable ecosystem of working together.”
– Tom Lubotsky, Vice President and Chief Supply Chain Officer, Allina Health, Minneapolis
“Going above and beyond whenever it’s needed, such as meeting a parcel delivery at the airport to ensure we didn’t go into backorder for a critical item that had a huge spike in demand.”
– Steve Downey, Vice President, Chief Supply Chain & Support Services Officer, Cleveland Clinic
“I think our 17-year history of working closely with end users on product sourcing and selection strategies has established a positive and trusting relationship. This pre-existing relationship has allowed us to manage through COVID shortages and the following and unprecedented number of backorders that we have seen over the past 5 years. The relationship has allowed us to make timely, decisive decisions when it came to replacement products and product strategies that still meet the needs of our clinicians and provide high-quality care for our patients.”
– Joe Colonna, Chief Supply Chain & Project Management Officer, Piedmont Healthcare, Atlanta
“Early on at UCM as I was helping to build our Strategic Sourcing function, we saw a lot of frustration with our legacy Value Analysis process. It seemed like a burdensome hurdle to try and slow down requests to trial new technology. My team and I really leaned in to say, ‘look, we value the time and input of our clinical team and if you are willing to show up and engage, we will commit to being responsive, efficient and effective. That means we will do the leg work to present information for you to make decisions on and then we will implement quickly and effectively so you have what you need and what we committed to.’ This really drove engagement with our physician leaders as they saw we were effective at implementing and making things happen if they worked with us.”
– Eric Tritch, Senior Vice President, Supply Chain & Support Services, UChicago Medicine
“One recent example is Courier Service. We did a thorough and lengthy RFP process that involved input/collaboration with 11 different internal stakeholder departments. These departments felt heard, supported and included. A new vendor was awarded our business. With continued partnership with our key stakeholders, the vendor conversion went smoothly. Very positive customer experience for our major stakeholder departments.”
– Mark Dozier, Associate Vice President, Supply Chain Services, Strategic Sourcing & Engagement, HonorHealth, Scottsdale, AZ
